Військове17 листопада 2026 р.

Hamas-led armed groups deliberately attacked and killed Israeli civilians on October 7.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld — псевдонім редакції «Факти та міфи» Hasbara. Статті цієї редакції пишуться та публікуються автоматично штучним інтелектом, і перед публікацією їх ніхто не перевіряє.

Міф

Hamas fighters did not target or kill any Israeli civilians on October 7, and all civilian casualties were caused by Israeli crossfire.

Факт

Hamas-led armed groups deliberately attacked and killed Israeli civilians on October 7. Israeli fire also caused some civilian deaths during the fighting, but evidence does not support the claim that it caused all civilian casualties.

The claim that Hamas fighters killed no Israeli civilians on October 7, 2023, and that every civilian death came from Israeli crossfire, reverses the documented record. Hamas-led armed groups deliberately attacked civilian communities and public gathering places, killing civilians and abducting others. Israeli forces did cause some civilian deaths during combat and hostage-rescue attempts. Those cases matter and deserve scrutiny; they do not erase the deliberate attacks or establish that Israeli fire caused all civilian deaths.

Armed groups attacked civilian sites

The United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry documented a coordinated assault beginning with rocket and mortar fire at 6:30 a.m., followed by armed men entering Israeli communities and attacking civilians. The Commission found that Hamas’s military wing and other armed groups intentionally directed attacks at civilians, murdered people, injured them and took hostages. It also described militants moving between homes, setting houses on fire and shooting people in shelters. These findings directly contradict the assertion that Hamas fighters did not target or kill civilians.

The Commission’s detailed investigation examined individual locations and incidents rather than relying only on broad statements. Its account records civilians killed in their homes, at public spaces and during the assault on communities. It also found that Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad publicly claimed rocket attacks and announced an intention to target civilian locations. The Commission’s report is based on interviews, forensic information, visual material and other evidence; its conclusions attribute intentional attacks and killings to armed-group members.

Human Rights Watch reached the same central conclusion after interviewing survivors, relatives, first responders, medical experts, municipal officials and journalists, and examining video and other material. Its investigation documented attacks on homes, roads, open fields, shelters and the Nova music festival. HRW found that gunmen used rifles, grenades and other weapons against civilians at close range. The group concluded that Hamas-led armed groups committed war crimes and crimes against humanity, including murder and extermination, during the assault.

Israeli fire caused some deaths

There is a real, narrower issue behind claims about Israeli fire: Israeli forces fought in crowded communities, sometimes amid hostage situations, and some civilians were killed by Israeli fire. The UN Commission reported that a woman abducted from Nir Oz was killed by Israeli helicopter fire. It also concluded that Israeli tank fire killed some or all of 13 civilian hostages held in a house in Be’eri. These findings are evidence of particular deaths, not evidence that Hamas killed no civilians.

Israel’s own inquiry into the Be’eri battle provides a more specific account of that hostage standoff. The Israel Defense Forces said its investigators found that no civilians inside the house were harmed by tank shells, while two civilians outside were injured by shrapnel; it assessed that most of the hostages were likely murdered by the terrorists. The UN Commission reached a different conclusion about deaths inside the house. The accounts should be attributed accurately: the disagreement concerns a particular incident and the evidence available to each investigation. Neither account supports a sweeping claim about every civilian killed across southern Israel that day.

The IDF inquiry also acknowledged major failures. Its account says security forces were unprepared for the scale of the simultaneous assault, struggled to understand events in Be’eri, and did not give residents sufficient warning in the initial hours. It records 101 civilians killed in the kibbutz, alongside 31 security personnel, as well as the abduction of hostages. Those facts describe both Hamas’s invasion and Israel’s failed defense; they do not convert the invasion’s civilian victims into deaths caused by Israeli forces.

Evidence does not support the blanket claim

Human Rights Watch says that, among cases where it received information about cause of death, evidence indicated only a minority of civilian deaths resulted from fighting between Israeli forces and armed groups, including deaths caused by Israeli forces. That qualification matters: HRW did not claim to know the cause of every death. But its finding runs opposite to the claim that all civilian casualties were caused by Israeli fire. HRW also documented numerous deliberate attacks by Hamas-led fighters, independent of the unresolved cause of death in particular firefights.

The Times of Israel reports on the IDF’s Paga post inquiry, which traces how Hamas fighters overran the post, killing or wounding nearly all the troops there and opening a route into nearby Be’eri. Its account cites the military probe’s conclusion that the IDF failed to defend the area. This chain of events helps explain why Israeli troops later fought across communities as they tried to stop the assault and rescue people. It does not make Hamas’s entry into civilian communities or its killings disappear.

The careful conclusion is neither that Israeli forces caused no civilian deaths nor that Hamas bears no responsibility for them. Evidence from the UN Commission, Human Rights Watch and Israeli investigations establishes that Hamas-led forces intentionally attacked and killed civilians, while Israeli fire also killed some civilians in specific incidents. The claim that Hamas fighters killed none and Israel caused every civilian death is false.

Джерела

  1. 1
  2. 2
    Questions and Answers: The Hamas-Led Armed Groups’ October 7, 2023 Assault on Israelhttps://www.hrw.org/news/2024/07/17/questions-and-answers-hamas-led-armed-groups-october-7-2023-assault-israelНенадійний
  3. 3
    Battle of Kibbutz Be’eri | The Inquiryhttps://www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/710-the-inquiries/all-of-the-710-inquiries/battle-of-kibbutz-beeri-the-inquiry/Надійний
  4. 4
    Fall of border post enabled Hamas invasion of Be’eri on Oct. 7, IDF probe findshttps://www.timesofisrael.com/fall-of-border-post-enabled-hamas-invasion-of-beeri-on-oct-7-idf-probe-finds/Надійний

Налаштування спеціальних можливостей

Ці налаштування зберігаються на цьому пристрої.

Попередній перегляд

Читайте так, як вам зручно

Налаштовуйте сторінку під час читання. Переглянути матеріали

Текст
Розмір текстуЗастосовується до всього сайту.
Колір і контрастність
Тема
Рух
АнімаціяНалаштування пристрою враховує зменшення руху.